- EF 151 and EF 152 are large classes that all engineering students take
- Each class is 4 credit hours – (Three 50 minute large lectures; two 75 minute rectations, 24 students/recitation)
- Want to find alternatives to large lecture (400-500 students in large class, 100-200 in small class)
- Discussion/interaction still difficult with a large class
- Material is very quantitative
- Textbook – recommended. Reading assignments, not effective, lots of other online resources.
- Have had Mediasite (151, 152) recorded lectures available for years
- Used tag-team teaching and clickers for years
- Don’t want to add more work for students
- Fall EF 151 students reported spending an average of 10.1 hours per week on homework
- A common theme in ASEE papers on flipped classroom has been to “create time” for active learning.
- Active learning already exists in EF courses through the recitation
Flipped Lectures
- Started with Friday lectures
- Created an equivalent online lecture consisting of multiple videos embedded into an online homework.
- Two slightly different approaches to using the lecture time
- EF 151
- “Flex Fridays” – optional attendance
- Give complete lecture
- No clickers (or clickers don’t count)
- All students have to answer video questions
- Approximately 30% attendance
- EF 152
- “Fabulous Fridays” – optional attendance
- Homework help/discussion or lecture summary + HW help
- No clickers
- All students have to answer video questions
- Approximately 8% attendance
- Spring, 2014 class primarily made up of Fall, 2014 EF 151 students
- EF 151
Online Lecture
- Videos embedded into an online homework (Demo requires UTK NetID login)
- Each video 5-10 minutes (approximately 1 video per slide)
- Videos made with Screencast-o-matic (PC/Tablet) or with Doceri (PC/iPad)
- Hosted on dedicated class web server
- Formatted to work with phone/tablet/computer
- One or two ‘simple’ questions per video
- Some educational research has suggested looking at questions first to help organize your thoughts
- After initial learning curve creation time is approximately 4 hours/lecture
- Harder to change topics/sequence/schedule
- A small mistake in the video is hard to fix
Evaluation
[visualizer id=”302″]
[visualizer id=”299″]
[visualizer id=”300″]
[visualizer id=”303″]
[visualizer id=”298″]
[visualizer id=”304″]
Conclusions
- Courses already had many aspects of a flipped lecture, so the real question is what is the best way to present the material.
- With many learning styles, there is no easy answer.
- First-year students seemed to struggle the most with time management/discipline to watch the video. However, these are valuable things for first-year students to learn.
- Just having Friday different may not be the most effective. Other options? All video lectures and 3 recitations per week? Smaller live lectures w/ recitations?